Lecture 1: Introduction

[Note: these are lightly edited versions of overheads and notes used in class. They are provided in order to help you study, but they are not a substitute for coming to class and being prepared. The notes are incomplete, and will often be hard to make sense of if you were not in class.]

Overview

Language is...

1. Systematic: symbols used as 'building blocks', the building blocks are arbitrary
2. Complex: knowledge-base in every speaker's head
3. Biological: humans seem to be 'built for language'

1. Components of language & arbitrariness

Variation in words shows arbitrary sound-meaning correspondences

hand (Engl)
main (French)
nsa (Twi)
ruka (Russian)

Building blocks of many different sizes: reusability makes for creativeness

Variation in how sounds are combined

Japanese

he-ri-co-pu-te-ra

English

he-li-cop-ter

Difference: Japanese (i) lacks an r/l contrast, (ii) requires syllables to have the shape Consonant-Vowel, hence the additional vowels.

Word Order Variation

There is a good deal of word order variation across languages, indicating that the word order that a language uses is somewhat arbitrary. [However, there are some word orders that are not found (e.g. e).]

1a. The dog chased the cat (English, French, Thai)
1b. The dog the cat chased (Japanese, Eskimo, Turkish)
1c. Chased the dog the cat (Irish, Hebrew, Tagalog)
1d. Chased the cat the dog (Huave, Coeur d&AtildeAlene)
1e. The chased dog the cat (!!!)

Similar cross-linguistic variation can be seen in morphology (how words are built).

 

2. Prodigious knowledge-base in every speaker

Investigation of language has shown that our knowledge of language is a prodigious system of unconscious knowledge. There are many things you 'know' about your language that you are quite unaware of.

What are the vowel sounds of American English?

In fact there are 15 for most speakers of American English ... were you aware of this? You already know it, in that you can easily recognize what are and are not vowels of your language.

beet
bait
boot
boat
bat
but
bite
boy
bit
bet
foot
bore
bar
sofa
bout

Some Grammatical and Ungrammatical Sentences of English

There are lots of things that you know about what is and is not a grammatical sentence of English, that you have never been taught or read in a grammar book.

2a. John kissed the old lady who owned the shaggy dog.
2b. The old lady kissed John who owned the shaggy dog.
2c. *Who owned the shaggy dog John kissed the old lady.
 
3a. John is difficult to love.
3b. It is difficult to love John.
3c. John is anxious to go.
3d. *It is anxious to go John.
 
4a. Ann looked the number up.
4b. Ann looked up the number.
4c. Ann looked it up.
4d. *Ann looked up it.
 
5. *More people have been to Paris than I have.

[Note: while most of the class shared the instructor's intuition that this sentence 'sounded fine', but turned out to be impossible to interpret, for one group of students were able to get the interpretation for this "Not just I have been to Paris".]

6a. Sue gave a painting to the museum.
6b. Sue gave the museum a painting.
6c. Sue donated a painting to the museum.
6d. *Sue donated the museum a painting.
 
7a. Who do you think John visited?
7b. Who do you think that John visited?
7c. Who do you think visited John?
7d. *Who do you think that visited John?

 

3. It's something we seem to be specialized for

Specific to humans: different from other animal systems.

Specialized parts of the brain handle it, e.g. Broca's area: needed for speaking

Learning it is linked to a biological schedule: if a person is exposed to language too late, he won't succeed in learning it (see move on Genie in second week of classes).

Linked to specific parts of the genetic code: genetic disorders have been reported which either make people have difficulties with language but not other mental abilities (Specific Language Impairment) or difficulties with many mental abilities, but not with language (Williams' Syndrome).

 

4. Prescriptive & Descriptive Grammar

Word meanings: descriptive and prescriptive (Websters & American Heritage)

a. hopefully
b. unique
c. bad

Grammaticality judgments (prescriptive)

ain't
no/any
split infinitives
whom
wanna

Systematicities about 'non-literary' English

a. Who do you want to visit (ambiguous)
b. Who do you wanna visit (unambiguous)
 
c. I didn't say anything/nothing
d. Nobody said that the photographers were accused of doing anything
e. Nobody said that the photographers were accused of doing nothing

(e) does not generally allow the interpretation of (d), for speakers who can use 'anything' or 'nothing' in (c). Interestingly, similar patterns are found in other languages which allow the equivalent of "I didn't say nothing" (in many languages such forms belong to the prestige dialect).

Arbitrariness of (non)-standard pronunciations

r-drop: UK mark of standard, r-usage provincial, uneducated etc.
r-drop: Massachussetts local non-prestige, r-usage is standard/prestige